I'd read before that Apple's supplier (Foxconn) was having trouble assembling iPhone 5s to Apple's standards… but this article contains some shocking stats: “Apple Returns Millions of Defective iPhone 5 Smartphones.”
Millions… 5 to 8 million defective phones returned. Foxconn has only been able to achieve an 80% quality rating… suggesting 2 in 10 have some sort of problem. What were Apple's expectations? Shockingly low.
The agreement between Apple and its outsourced manufacturer allegedly states that a 90 percent quality rate is required (meaning only 1 out of 10 iPhones are allowed to be broken).
I'm pretty shocked that Apple expected (or allowed) a 10% defect rate.
The bad working conditions at Foxconn have been well documented (including this previous blog post of mine).
This goes to show there are multiple definitions of quality, including:
Fitness for use: Does the product, as designed, meet the customer's needs?
Lack of defects: Not having physical problems or electrical problems
This is a VERY high defect rate for manufacturing. That's hardly a six sigma quality level.
Having to take back the defective product add costs and hurts profit margins for Foxconn.
What do you think? Please scroll down (or click) to post a comment. Or please share the post with your thoughts on LinkedIn – and follow me or connect with me there.
Did you like this post? Make sure you don't miss a post or podcast — Subscribe to get notified about posts via email daily or weekly.
Check out my latest book, The Mistakes That Make Us: Cultivating a Culture of Learning and Innovation:
Hi Mark
A 10% defect rate must be why Apple products cost so much extra, it is fortunate for them they are so cutting edge, if they weren’t they would have been out of business years ago with such poor quality.
But I guess poor quality goes hand in hand with there just get it to market mindset. Quality production requires some time and effort to set up.
Yeah, it’s a good thing they can charge a premium for their products (an iPad mini is $100 than a Kindle Fire). Apple might be fooling themselves that the cost of poor quality is stuck on their suppliers, but it ultimately flows through to them.
[…] Apple Expected 10% Bad iPhones from Foxconn? Mark Graban’s Lean Blog, May 6, […]